How to Negotiate a Lower Comcast Xfinity Bill

My Xfinity Price Negotiation Strategy to Lower my Bill

Comcast, or “Xfinity” as they like to call themselves these days, had thrown me for a bit of a loop lately. The live-chat method had always worked for me in getting discounts and promotions on Comcast services, but lately they’ve been sticklers. I had written a very old post on the Get Rich Slowly site in the past that highlighted how to cut your Comcast bill – and gave the actual chat transcript that cut my cost by 33%. That post is outdated, and few have had much luck with Xfinity’s live chat team in recent years. Maybe Comcast management read that post and decided to “toughen up” the live chat team? Whatever the case, new Xfinity negotiation tactics were needed.

Sure, I could get rid of cable completely. But, I love live sports and find enough educational value in other programming. And stacking streaming packages can cost just as much, if not more, than cable TV these days. So, I decided to go back to my old method of getting a Comcast discount – a good ole’ fashion negotiation by phone.

Before I go into the negotiation and what the result was, I’ll first highlight what my package and price was (post 2-year contract expiring):

  1. “Popular TV” with HD DVR: $90/month with fees (full price)
  2. “Fast” Cable Internet (400 Mbps): $40/month (discounted)

Total price: $130 per month (+ another $25 or so for other related fees).

Note: Xfinity frequently changes their speeds and package pricing and names, so research what the current offerings are in your area, and substitute in the script. It’s the technique – speak to the right representative, threaten to cancel, get offered a bundle at new customer pricing, eliminate fees – that works, not the product branding or even pricing specifics.

cut Xfinity bill

How to Cut your Comcast Bill: Step-by-Step Phone Script

I’ll now walk you step-by-step how I was able to negotiate by Xfinity price down to $90 per month.

1. I picked up the phone and called Xfinity customer service number @: 1-800-934-6489 (1-800-XFINITY).

2. I state (“disconnect service”) when prompted by the automated voice prompts.

This should get you connected to an Xfinity loyalty or retention specialist, who have more power to offer discounts than other customer service reps.

3. I lead my negotiation with the competition.

Comcast fears losing customers to AT&T U-Verse, who is offering up some great discounted packages to new customers.

My discussion was almost identical to this – and this Comcast script has reportedly worked well for hundreds of readers:

  • Me: I’d like to discontinue my service.
  • Comcast Rep: OK, may I ask why?
  • Me: Because I need to lower my bill and AT&T U-Verse is now available in my neighborhood and has some great offers for me, including fiber internet and streaming for much less than I am currently paying. Or, I’ve been looking at a few streaming services as well.
  • Comcast Rep: OK. Well AT&T doesn’t offer as many HD channels, but I can look to see what kind of package we may be able to offer you.
  • Me: OK, I’ll hear you out.
  • Comcast Rep: OK, so we have a new offer where you can give you the same price as a new customer, with a 2-year contract: $79.99 for Fast 400 Mbps and Popular TV cable with 125 channels. There is also a $10/month DVR fee.
  • Me: Are you able to cut the DVR fee?
  • Comcast Rep: Now you can cut the Xfinity HD DVR and set top box fee (my tips on how to do this), but you need to stay under 20 hours of programming recorded. If you don’t want a DVR, there is a $8.50/month set-top box fee per device (note: now $10/month per device), but you can get rid of that by using a Roku with the Xfinity Stream app, Amazon Fire, or certain smart TVs. You can also sign up for eco-bill and get a discount there. After all of that, your price would be $93 with a 2-year contract.
  • Me: Are you sure you don’t have any cheaper packages?
  • Comcast Rep: Yes.
  • Me: OK, please make the switch.
  • Comcast Rep: OK, should we add on Xfinity Voice too?
  • Me: No thanks (I have Ooma digital phone service, and it’s free).

Score another one versus Comcast’s dreaded customer service.

4. I Saved 34%!

I was able to cut $47 (34%) off my cable/internet package, while getting the same channels and same internet speeds. Over 2 years, this will save me $1,128, and then I will negotiate a new 2-year contract again, or switch to U-Verse.

5. Stay Congenial

I want to point out that I was friendly, yet confident with the service rep. It may sound cliche, but treat others as you would want to be treated and you will get better results. Act like a jerk, and you’ll strike out.

6. Bundling Often Results in a Better Deal

If you’re going to be an Xfinity customer, it almost always saves you money when you bundle. Xfinity frequently has deals that allow you to bundle Xfinity Mobile with Xfinity TV and Internet, lowering the combined total prices of those services – often with prepaid Visa cards as a reward. If you live with an Xfinity Internet/TV supported area, bundling Xfinity Mobile (see my Xfinity Mobile Review for more info) with those services will usually result in the lowest total price versus buying from separate providers. You can find current Xfinity bundle offers here if you’re interested in bundling services.

7. Eliminate Extra Fees where you Can

Important Note: I also previously got rid of the Comcast modem fee by purchasing my own modem and router – saving me another $15 per month (yes, Comcast has recently raised their modem rental price). This is something you 100% must do too. This is in addition to the $10/month TV box fee noted above.

Comcast has recently been advertising Xfinity “Supersonic Wi-Fi” offering. Broken down, “Supersonic Wi-Fi” is really just Xfinity’s fastest (and highest cost) internet tiers (Gigabit or Ultrafast plans) paired with a new Wi-Fi 6E router (which they are marketing as the “Supersonic Gateway” as part of their package Xfinity “Supersonic Bundle” deal). Even better – Wi-Fi 7 is now new in the market. I recently took a look at the new Wi-Fi 7 versus Wi-Fi 5, 6, & 6E technology to determine if Wi-Fi 7 is worth the cost.

I don’t think it’s worth it. I would recommend replacing your Xfinity xFi modem by buying a Arris S33 modem and pairing it with a TP-Link AX3000 (Wi-Fi 6), TP-Link AXE5400 (Wi-Fi 6E), or TP-Link BE9300 (Wi-Fi 7) router if I were buying today (see the articles linked to on the “Important Note” above for a full list of good modem/router options). This setup offers the same speeds as Xfinity and pays for itself in just over a year (saving $180 per year), and then it’s free for as long as they live!

I’ve also written more broadly on how to get rid of your ISP modem rental fee (if you’re not a Comcast customer).

Cut your Comcast Xfinity Bill Discussion:

  • What did your Comcast negotiation look like? How much did you save and how did you get it?
  • Comcast CSR’s: Now is your chance to tell all! How can customers get the best deals and how does Comcast set these policies (retention specialist can negotiate/others cannot). Please share! (you’ll remain anonymous, of course)

Related Posts:


  1. Micah
    • luchetti
      • Mark
      • AlwaysFackingComcastInDaArse
        • Mary
      • Phyllis Tobin
        • Adrianne Todisco
        • Kevin Konieczny
      • Mars
        • pete Dziadyk
    • Tiffany Eberhart
      • Cara
        • Adrianne Todisco
      • BONNIE LOU
      • Greg
    • Jan
      • Ned M
        • Suckmya55
        • JM
        • Dave
    • Zalgo
    • Liz Littlejohn
    • Kate
      • Bob
    • Sally Reid
  2. BZ
  3. Elcobydos
    • Michelle
  4. matt
    • anonymous
      • stacy
        • Hunter
      • Babs
      • Themaninthemoon
        • morey000
          • Darren
      • Lori Smith
        • Lori Smith
    • Debbie
  6. Blake
  7. Mike
  8. anonymous
    • Angel
  9. Sher
    • Comcast Hater
      • Nice Man
  10. dkrobinson
    • David
  11. Mallorie
  12. Coleman
    • Wayne
    • G
  13. I. M. Caveman
  14. Rick
  15. Maximus
    • kathy
  16. Sean Smith
  17. hi
  18. Ed
  19. CJ
    • Comcast Hater
  20. Debra B
  21. Dogstardaddy
  22. Justin
  23. PapaFi
    • Ml
      • timothy
  24. PG
    • Blake
  25. enyalid
  26. StingerDawg
  27. Liz Clevesy
    • Comcast Hater
  28. Jim
    • Beth
  29. Karen
  30. Cel
      • Cel
    • Cate
      • chris
      • Jk
      • JimW
  31. Michael
  32. DD
  33. jmm
  34. AA
  35. Eric
  36. Justin
  37. Wahine
  38. Kim
  39. Bill
  40. mandy smith
  41. Jason
  42. Wendy Piklor
  43. Lori in Leesburg
  44. Randi
  45. Kalifah
  46. Jupvega
    • Jupvega
  47. Raven 1735
  48. NLLCGA
  49. VideoGuy
  50. BevB
  51. Nina
  52. BassMan
    • JXI
      • huy awed
        • Mike
  53. Sandra
  54. Rob
  55. Lisa
  56. George
  57. Dan
  58. John
  59. Chris
    • JXI
  60. David
  61. The Cretin
  62. bob
  63. Ann
    • Lisa
  64. Eli
    • Eli
  65. kent
  66. Lisa
  67. Tom Laurin
  68. Anthony
  69. William
  70. Alan Gunn
  71. yogimom
    • junglerabbit
  72. Devlin
  73. junglerabbit
  74. I GOT MINE
  75. Erica
  76. Steven
  77. Johnny
  78. G-Rock
  79. Tim
    • JXI
  80. Rodger Hilger
  81. Steve
  82. Jake
  83. tom
  84. Dale
  85. Jeff
  86. Samantha
  87. erik
    • Zeke
  88. Dex
    • STG
  89. TP
  90. Satisfied Man
  91. SC
  92. AA
  93. Sandra B
  94. Bergie
  95. mickie
  96. Lynn
    • AcousticRebel
  97. Eric
  98. Beetsy
  99. thanks
  100. Albert
  101. anami
    • anami
  102. Preston
  103. Don
    • Linwood
  104. Dean
  105. Shaun
  106. Deb
    • Bill
      • Braxton Pusher
  107. Joel Lukacher
  108. Donna Horowitz
  109. Kevin Cosman
  110. Leslie G
    • Braxton Pusher
    • maureen
  111. Peter P
  112. deb
    • Braxton Pusher
      • stavesacre
  113. MD Jenkins
  114. Agua Caliente
  115. Bob Dole
  116. Anon
    • martino
    • Frances Davis
    • M B
    • Carl
    • SM
  117. Anon
  118. Happy
  119. Courtney
  120. EL_DIABLO
  121. L T
  122. EL_Diablo
    • Anon
  123. Robin
  124. GTrain
  125. Greg
  126. JAN in ATLANTA
  127. Steve
  128. Elfnet
    • bsdetector
      • Boschslppr
  129. KD
  130. JXY
  131. enter be
  132. A. Nonymous
  133. GG
    • GG
  134. Chinue X
  135. Bonita
  136. Malcolm
  137. Peter
  138. Regina Robison
  139. james
  140. Andrew
  141. Ray
  142. Steve
    • Steve
  143. Ray
  144. D
  145. Josh
  146. Chris
  147. Malcolm
  148. Remy desaulnier
  149. JF
  150. jcshas
  151. Malcolm
  152. Darren
  153. G
    • Darren Brown
      • Gio
        • Darren
          • Gio
          • comcastVictim
  154. Darren
    • GIo
  155. GrayGhost
  156. RG
  157. Regina M Robison
  158. Andrew
  159. Eric
    • Jim
  160. Samantha
  161. Jim
    • Jim
  162. Kendra
  163. japanjazzy
    • James
  164. David
  165. GroincastorSenilelink
  166. DTMS
  167. Bobby
  168. Nestor Cardona
  169. Terry S.
  170. MW
  171. On a mission
  172. Chill
  173. morey000
  174. Lori Smith
  175. Ira
  176. Andrew
  177. Andrew
  178. LJ
  179. LJ
  180. DH
  181. Pat T
  182. Doug
  183. LJ
  184. skyjake
  185. Alec
  186. LN
  187. Debra Morgan
  188. Anonymous
  189. Glellie
  190. Scott Avery
  191. ZombieTech
  192. Howard
  193. Albert
  194. JC
  195. cd
  196. Noble
  197. Ron Weisberg

Leave a Reply