Xfinity Raised their Modem Rental Fee. Again. You have Options.
Not long ago, Comcast Xfinity raised their modem rental fee price to $15/month, up from $14 previously (in addition to a number of other price increases). This makes Xfinity’s xFi annual modem rental fee $180! If you have opted for the “xFi Complete” option, your cost was previously increased to $25/month ($300 per year)!
Xfinity’s new modem rental price increases quietly hit customer’s bills, with notification buried deep on pages 4 and 5 of the prior month’s bill. Can Comcast raise modem rental and other fees, even if you have a contracted package price with them?
It turns out, they can. Xfinity states the following on a Xfinity bill changes page:
If you have a promotional price or minimum-term agreement for specific services, prices for those services won’t change until that period ends. However, taxes, fees (such as the Broadcast TV Fee, Regional Sports Network Fee, or equipment charges), and charges for additional TVs may increase.
Bolded emphasis on “equipment charges”, e.g. gateway/modem/router/TV Box/DVR devices. In addition to raising their modem rental fees over the years, Xfinity also recently raised their monthly TV box fee again from $10 to $12 per month ($144 per year) in early 2025. The good news is that you can replace your Xfinity DVR & TV Box with your own compatible streaming device like a Roku, Amazon Fire stick, Apple TV, or Chromecast, saving you that $12 per month ($144/year) per device. Full details at that link.
Fortunately, you can wipe out that Xfinity modem rental fee cost as well.
Cutting your Comcast Modem Rental Fee to Nothing is Easy
$180 per year ($15 x 12 months) is a steep price to pay to simply borrow an Xfinity “xFi” modem/gateway that is not yours to own when you can get the same or better speed and reliability from your own devices. And, while Comcast’s modem rental prices keep going up, the actual price for you to purchase equipment that is at least as equally as functional as Comcast’s has steeply declined.
This makes the prospect of ditching your rented Comcast Xfinity modem/router for your own even more lucrative than it has been in the past.
I’ve previously written about how to replace your Xfinity modem with your own as the most efficient way to get rid of your Xfinity modem rental fee and cut your Comcast bill (without having to negotiate with Comcast). The process is the same as replacing any ISP’s modem with your own, so this lesson is applicable to any ISP that allows you to do so:
- Buy a compatible modem and router (see my recommendations below).
- Connect your devices.
- Call Xfinity tech support to activate your new modem (if it does not activate online using the Xfinity self-install instructions when you plug it in). Xfinity’s customer service number is 1-800-934-6489 (1-800-XFINITY).
- Return your leased modem – and get a receipt in case they try to charge you (keep an eye on future bills to make sure the modem rental fee is removed)! Here is a list of Xfinity’s store locations where you can return your device.
What Should I Replace my Comcast Modem/Router with?
Comcast touts their gateways (a wired modem + wireless router combo housed in 1 device) as something special. They aren’t. Any of the following Comcast-supported modem/router combinations will have similar function at today’s (and the foreseeable future’s) connection speeds. I have spent weeks researching every Xfinity compatible modem and would opt for a a fast modem (either a Netgear CM3000 or Motorola B12) to pair with a Wi-Fi 7 router (either a Netgear Nighthawk BE9300 or a TP-Link BE9300), but any of the below modem + router combos will work great for 99.9% of users. If you want Voice (VOIP) capabilities, you can connect an Ooma to your router. More on that below.
Recommend Xfinity-Compatible Modems (to pair with any router below):
These Xfinity-compatible cable modems have the latest/greatest technology and will be able to meet the top ISP speeds for a long time. All are top sellers on Amazon with 4+ star customer ratings, are equipped with the latest DOCSIS 3.1 technology, have over 1Gbps (=1,000Mbps, or 1 “Gig”) speed capabilities, and have been chosen for great value for their price. If you’re paying for top speeds with Xfinity, go with one of these.
- Netgear CM3000: up to 2330Mbps
- Motorola B12: up to 2330Mbps
- Hitron Coda56: up to 2330Mbps
- Arris S34: up to 2330Mbps
If you want Xfinity Voice, go with the Netgear CM2050v (up to 2330Mbps). Note: you can just as easily (and at a big cost savings) add landline voice (VOIP) functionality by simply connecting an Ooma device to your router.
If you want a gateway (modem + router combined in 1 device), I don’t recommend that because they aren’t as reliable, are pricier, and you can’t upgrade one half, but the Arris G54 (up to 2334Mbps modem + Wi-Fi 7 router) is the best modern option. Note: if you buy this gateway, you do not need a router below.
Recommended Routers (to pair with any modem above):
I did a breakdown of Wi-Fi 7 versus Wi-Fi 5, 6, & 6E technology. Wi-Fi 7 is easily the best Wi-Fi technology for the modern internet and household Wi-Fi demands. Now that it’s been on the market for a while, it also provides the best value for your money. Compared to Wi-Fi 6E (the most recent generation), Wi-Fi 7 doubled the amount of simultaneous high speed connected devices – and increased maximum speeds. Just make sure you get a tri-band Wi-Fi 7 router, which adds a 6GHz band – not all of them have it. Here are my picks for the best value Wi-Fi 7 routers (all with tri-band) on the market at the moment:
- Netgear Nighthawk BE9300 – Wi-Fi 7: up to 9300Mbps (5800Mbps on the 6GHz, 2900Mbps on the 5GHz band, 700Mbps on the 2.4GHz band)
- TP-Link BE10000 Mesh – Wi-Fi 7: use solo or as a mesh system with up to 10000Mbps (5188Mbps on the 6GHz, 4324Mbps on the 5GHz band, 574 Mbps on the 2.4GHz band)
- Amazon Eero 7 Pro – Wi-Fi 7: up to 5000Mbps (3900Mbps on the 6GHz, unspecified speeds for 5GHz band and 2.4GHz bands)
- TP-Link BE9300 – Wi-Fi 7: up to 9300Mbps (5760Mbps on the 6GHz, 2880Mbps on the 5GHz band, 574 Mbps on the 2.4GHz band)
With these modem and router combos, you will pay a 1-time cost and then save the $180 (xFi gateway) or $300 annually (xFi complete) that Xfinity will charge, and then save that amount for many years to come. It’s really not that hard, I promise. Buy a modem and a router, connect your cable internet line, power them up, and you’re good to go! Money in the bank.
Related Posts:
if you have Comcast Xfinity home phone service, you must use a specific type of modem that has the phone connection built into it. There seems to be only one , an Arris model that sells in the $200 plus range.
Don’t pay for XFinity home phone. Complete ripoff. If you want VOIP, you can get it for nearly free with Ooma, and Ooma will work with ANY of these modem/router combos: https://20somethingfinance.com/ooma-review-1-year-after-making-the-switch/
This is a great public service, I’ve saved over $300. with my Arris 6183 and never had a glitch. To save even more there are rebuilds for about $30.. Plug it in, make the call and start counting the savings. Also; why would anyone use their phone service when Magicjack costs $15. A Year! Or.. you could just keep complaining about the cable bill!
I bought two refurbished Ari’s modems for $30 each. One is a backup. Only had one die in 10 years…. So I have $90 in modem costs total.
For the technical neophyte, please remember, if you do buy your own modem and or router, you may need to contact the manufacturers for device related technical support.
You wouldn’t call Ford to help you with a Chevy, would you?
The modem/router customer service is actually excellent. They will walk you through, on the phone, how to set up the equipment, how to solve any glitches, how to re-connect it if there’s an outage or something, what to do in any situation. Their instructions included in the package walk you through exactly how to change your devices’ passwords to prevent hacking, something that Comcast never even mentions. With Comcast’s equipment you’re completely on your own to figure that out.
I haven’t rented a modem from them for more than ten years now, and not only do I enjoy the savings, what I most appreciate is the ready help of the equipment companies and dealing with them instead of having to speak with Comcast. Not that there’s much need: the equipment quality is excellent. It’s just if you need help in connecting or setup in any odd situation, their customer service will get it done for you, and quickly.
Even if in a contract, you can still replace the modem with your own, in order to cancel out the modem rental fee.
We use a cheap modem/router combo from Arris and it works fine. Unless you know you’re gonna use the service for only a few months (i.e. moving away soon and switching provider), I don’t see why anyone would rent a modem.
I actually tried the TP Link AC1200 and my speeds were about 150mbps when I was paying Comcast for 250mbps. So I got a tech to my house to use the Xfi modem/router and voila, 290mbps. I seriously think they put restrictions on 3rd party modem/routers.
It was more likely your modem. If your modem was delivering 250Mbps, the AC1200 would have been close to that. The AC1200 is capable of 1200Mbps (provided the modem delivers up to the speed).
I live in Washington DC and am in the process of signing up for Comcast. I told them I was going to bring my own modem and they told me that’d fine but there would be a $60 charge for me to do so. Have you ever heard of anything like this? Could I have misunderstood then and the charge is for something else that’s standard? Sounds like BS to me.
Interesting. Curious if there are other data points here. If a new policy, I would refuse to sign up w/ them if they add this fee. I would imagine that reps have freedom to waive it.
$60 might be the price cost of the installation, sometimes they charge $60 due to the fact that the tap status outside your house is already disabled/disconnected.
I just received my bill today and they pretty much jacked up the prices on everything. It’s bad enough that if you wanted an internet-only service then it would cost more than their Triple Play Package. This is a great article G. E . Miller. I just posted something similar on my site on cutting rental costs by getting rid of their TV Box and remote. Come check it out if you can. Cheers!
techsavvyone.com
I recently had enough of the increase rental fees with Comcast. I finally talked to someone who actually said I can change from Triple Play to Double Play and my bill will go down by $ 27.00 a month. Yah Hoo! Some one finally understands I do not want the house phone number that gets constant robo calls and we never use! So out that went, I then returned the rental modem and additional tv box. Another price decrease ($21.00]in my monthly bill! I encourage all to at least buy your own Modem and get a Roku streaming stick if you are using one of their boxes. You won’t be sorry. The Roku is compatible with xfinity and you get all your local channels with the xfinity streaming app.
We already have our own modem and they want to charge $25/mo.,how do I get out of this?