3 Reasons why Tax Refunds are Bad & how Allowances can Help

Update to the below content: tax allowances reflected ‘tax exemptions’, which were removed with the Tax Cuts & Jobs Act (tax reform) that went into effect in 2018 in favor of higher standard deductions. As a result, the IRS launched a new W4-Form that should be used by taxpayers looking to change their tax withholdings. See that article for more info on tax withholding and the below content covers tax allowances for historical reference and has some withholding tax tools that are applicable to today.

Tax Allowances Are Key to More Income

Tax allowances are the key to more income throughout the year. Unfortunately very few people know how they work. It’s that time of year when many people start to get giddy about getting that fat tax refund they’ve been waiting for. According to the IRS, the average tax refund in recent years has hovered around $3,150 per filed return. What many of us, particularly younger professionals, don’t realize or don’t want to accept, is that getting that huge refund is really a poor financial strategy.

The reason why anyone would be able to receive a huge refund is mostly going to be due to the fact that they were paying the government too much withholding tax on their income throughout the year in the first place. A lot of people realize this, but don’t seem to know how to take action. Personally speaking, I have fallen into that psychological trap as well, where you think by getting a large refund you are somehow better off financially for it. Getting that large check in the mail feels like a huge blessing. Quite the opposite is true.

tax allowances

The Drawbacks to getting a Large Refund

1. You are loaning your money for a negative return. Getting a large refund means you are paying more in taxes throughout the year. This money could easily be going into your bank account and earning interest throughout the year. Let’s say that you invest the extra income in mutual funds and you earn the stock market historical average, in effect you’re loaning the government your cash and in return for your kind offer you are giving them a good chunk of cash. Even if you just put the money into a low-interest checking account that returned 1% a year, consider it a 1% loss on the amount of your refund.

2. You are binging and purging your cash. Getting more of your true income delivered to you on a consistent basis allows you to work it into your budget. If you direct deposit this income into your savings, you don’t miss it at all. The urge for many, when they receive a big refund, is to go out and spend it because they feel that they deserve it. They do, after all, it’s their hard earned cash! If you set yourself up to not get that big refund, there’s no urge to purge.

3. You are not able to distribute investment risk evenly over time. Part of any good investment strategy is to distribute risk of loss by adding investment contributions over time. Even if you wisely invest your refund versus spending it all, you would most likely be making one large contribution versus spreading out risk over the year. This is a bad investment practice.

The Basics of Withholding Tax Allowance Exemptions

A withholding tax allowance is simply a number than you can claim on your W4 form that will change the amount of your income that your employer will withhold from you throughout the year. The number of allowances can vary, but is most likely 0, 1, or 2. The higher the allowance number, the less tax will be withheld from you with each paycheck. A W4 is filled out by an employee when they start employment.

Allowances on a W4 can be updated at any time by filling out a new one. Most employers will allow you to do this whenever you desire (and as often as you desire), and your withholding tax amounts should take effect in your next full pay period (this may differ by employer, so ask yours).

Don’t Take Tax Allowances Too Far

On the other end of things, you don’t want to end up owing the IRS significant money and possible penalties. Just be careful.

Your End Goal with Withholding Taxes

Ideally, at the end of the year, you will benefit the most if you receive a very small refund (close to nothing) or end up paying a very slight amount that you will be able to easily pay. One caveat when changing allowances: the last thing you want to do is end up with too high of an allowance that results in you owing a high amount that you are unable to pay.

How can I Figure out what my Tax Allowance should be?

Fortunately, there are at least three free resources available to you, which are cited below. If you still are having trouble figuring out what your allowance should be, you may want to speak with your employer’s payroll department or a qualified tax professional.

Will you be changing your allowances in the coming year?

Related Posts:


  1. Dan
  2. G.E. Miller
  3. Michael
  4. G.E. Miller
  5. Michael
  6. G.E. Miller
  7. Freddie
  8. G.E. Miller
  9. stephanie
  10. G.E. Miller
  11. Andrew
    • Natalie
  12. J.D.
    • Natalie
  13. G.E. Miller
  14. William
  15. G.E. Miller
  16. sheehan
  17. CJEH
  18. Cj
  19. torg
  20. diane
  21. jp
  22. create pay stub
  23. Natalie
  24. Natalie
  25. j
  26. Jim
  27. RNT
    • Joseph
    • Nikki
  28. Justin
  29. Cindy
  30. khan
  31. brian
    • chris
    • dj
  32. dan
  33. Prachi
  34. Michael
  35. Clayton jones
  36. Doug
  37. Larisa

Leave a Reply