Would you Support your Financially Negligent Parents?

Filial Responsibility: State Laws that Mandates Adult Children Pay for Parental Care

On the surface, the answer of whether or not you should support your parents in their later years is an easy one – yes, of course you should, right? You don’t want to see them aimlessly walking around the neighborhood, begging for food and meds. Besides, you would be paying them back for raising you and paying your expenses and maybe even helping you financially with your education.




But… what if your parents decided to live a very extravagant lifestyle and made zero effort to boost their retirement savings? And were ignorantly or purposefully negligent in their financial decisions. Should you support their retirement then?

Family is family, but you didn’t exactly have a choice about supporting yourself when you were brought into this world. You were a dependent with no alternative and really no freedom of choice to earn an income. You were entitled out of necessity.

filial responsibility

Parents who don’t make conscious decisions to invest in their retirement and live below their means DO have a choice. They are choosing present or future financial entitlement and opting to think about themselves instead of the family members that they eventually become dependent on.

Taking that a step further, what if they were 100% capable of earning an income to delay withdrawing from a tiny nest egg, but instead choose to not work at all and live now off of their paltry savings, knowing full well that in a few years they would be 100% dependent on their children or other family members? Do you still owe it to them to support them and that behavior?

 




Like it or not, I think this is going to become more and more of the norm. Baby boomers are going to demand retirement (ignorantly or not), and as I explored last week in my inheritance post, their average retirement savings are dismal:

  • Only 15% aged 44-54 have over $250,000 saved
  • Only 19% aged 55+ have over $250,000 saved.
  • 44% aged 44-54 have less than $10,000 in total savings.
  • 29% aged 55+ have less than $10,000 in total savings.

Even if your parents are in that stark minority (15 or 19%) with a decent amount of savings, would you feel safe having them retire to never work again on that amount of savings? I sure wouldn’t.

The thing is, you may not even have a choice, due to filial responsibility. At least 30 states have filial responsibility laws that mandate adult children must pay for their parents basic life needs, should they need it, including nursing home care.

States with some level of filial responsibility laws include:

  • Alaska
  • Arkansas
  • California
  • Connecticut
  • Delaware
  • Georgia
  • Idaho
  • Indiana
  • Iowa
  • Kentucky
  • Louisiana
  • Maryland
  • Massachusetts
  • Mississippi
  • Montana
  • Nevada
  • New Hampshire
  • New Jersey
  • North Carolina
  • North Dakota
  • Ohio
  • Oregon
  • Pennsylvania
  • Rhode Island
  • South Dakota
  • Tennessee
  • Utah
  • Vermont
  • Virginia
  • West Virginia

Look in to your states specific laws in detail, as the laws may differ.

Filial Responsibility Law Discussion:

For the sake of discussion, let’s imagine you DO have a choice and your parents lives aren’t entirely dependent on your decision. If your parents were negligent in their financial decision-making and you had your own family and self to financially look after, would you still foot their bills for them?

256 Comments

  1. Trevor
    • DAN
    • Noway
      • Raphaela
        • Suhaila
      • PJ
      • Dawn Monaco
      • Cherilyn
        • Amanda
          • Generation X
            • Deborah McC
            • sarah
          • Maria
          • Spilled Milk
        • Evon
        • Elba
        • Jennifer Wood
        • Emily
        • Lani
      • Megan
      • Stacia
        • Amanda
    • Grant
    • Sharon
      • Fala
  2. Matthew
      • BG
        • kim
          • Ronna
          • anne
          • nema
          • Nicole
          • Tony
          • Leah
          • Jeaane
          • Sharon
            • deedi
        • Dang Smith
          • PennyRex
          • Common Cents
            • Unfair
          • WM
          • Elizabeth
          • texan
          • Michelle
        • Genny
          • Common Cents
          • Miss Lady
          • Scott
          • Mary
        • Rebecca
          • Tony
            • dee
      • Jen
        • andrea
    • KRJC
  3. Leah
    • Dang Smith
      • Brian
      • Common Cents
      • Common Cents
      • michael49022
    • Shawn
      • Jo Gunter
      • Sam
    • Common Cents
    • Yorkshirebird
    • Amber
      • Cristina
        • shy
          • Ricardo
        • Sarah
    • jeffrey
      • jeffrey
    • Miss Lady
    • June Banahan
    • Financially Unresponsible Parents Sucks Ass
  4. ERHR
  5. David
  6. Brandy
  7. Little Miss Moneybags
  8. K C -Stl
    • Paula
  9. Jason
  10. Vanessa
  11. Natalie
    • Tony
  12. Ron Ablang
    • jeffrey
  13. Amanda
      • Amanda
        • Rommee
  14. Trisha
    • Michelle
  15. matt
    • Nicole
  16. PigPennies
  17. Melissa
  18. Leslie
  19. Agatha Kulesza
  20. LaTisha @YoungAdultFinances
  21. Eric
    • Agatha Kulesza
  22. Jennifer
    • bschild79
      • dt
    • JWB
  23. BW
    • Agree with BW
  24. Quita
  25. Freaked Out
    • Tony
    • kimba999
    • Lani
  26. Yiiup
  27. So Angry!!!!
    • Advice
  28. Angry, Frustrated, & Confused
  29. angela t
  30. theresa
  31. Leslie
    • Sue
  32. YoungNOTDumb
    • Tony
  33. Frustrated
  34. Thomas Armstrong
    • Common Cents
  35. Justannoyed
    • Real Advice
  36. Another 2 sense
  37. Zack
    • Common Cents
      • Real Advice
  38. Kristine
    • Real Advice
  39. DMG
    • Real Advice
  40. janiie
  41. Louie
    • Louie
  42. Lisa
  43. Shannon
  44. Shannon
    • Rebecca
  45. Chi123
    • amber
  46. Tiffany
    • amber
      • Lani
  47. amber
    • Louie
      • amber
    • Kim
  48. Kim
    • Lettia
  49. Pansters
    • nema
      • Bingo
        • MJ
      • Lettia
    • sue
      • Lettia
  50. Walla
  51. Debbie Graham
  52. Andie
  53. X
  54. Publius
  55. Bingo
  56. Mission Viejo
  57. Florida
  58. sue
  59. JC
    • JC
  60. Taluah
  61. D
    • JC
      • Junglechicken
        • Suhaila
    • klm
  62. JD
    • Tony
  63. D'oh!
  64. Jay
  65. tay
  66. Brittany
    • Jen
  67. Jen
    • Brittany
      • Sharon
  68. Toka
    • Amanda
      • Toka
  69. Carrie
    • Suhaila
  70. Hopeless
    • Suhaila
    • Suhaila
  71. Ally
  72. Paul
    • FilialPietyIsAMeme
      • Fala
  73. KD
  74. alice
  75. alice
    • Suhaila
    • Suhaila
  76. Japorska
  77. help me
    • Suhaila
  78. drmunch
    • Suhaila
    • FilialPietyIsAMeme
  79. Snottykid
  80. Alice
  81. Jon
  82. Sunshiney
    • FilialPietyIsAMeme
  83. Megan
  84. Sue
    • FilialPietyIsAMeme
  85. Jane
  86. 121GW
  87. Dave
    • Sunshine
      • darth smith
  88. darth smith
  89. Perry Burrow
  90. Susie
  91. JWB
  92. pc
  93. Thom B.
  94. Zan
  95. Kathi
  96. Tim
    • Sue
  97. Navin
    • Sue
  98. FilialPietyIsAMeme
  99. Danielle Daniel
  100. Tiffany
  101. Lettia
  102. Michelle Stewart
  103. Amber
  104. Anonymous
  105. Jenny
  106. Angela
  107. Monster in Law
  108. Elise

Join 10,000+ wealth builders. Get new articles by email, for free.

Thank you for subscribing!

Oops... Please try again.