Self-Employed Retirement Plan Faceoff: SEP IRA vs Solo 401k vs SIMPLE IRA
While completing my taxes this year, I started noticing that I would have a sizable tax bill due from self-employment income unless I found a way to reduce my taxable income.
Our (my wife and I file jointly) income levels were beyond where I could contribute to a Traditional IRA (phaseout starts at $98K) – so that was not an option. And contributing to a Roth IRA (after-tax) would have defeated the whole purpose of reducing taxable income.
So, after six years of running this blog and having (mostly tiny) side self-employment income beyond my day job, I decided to look in to retirement plans for self-employment income.
I found three options, which I highlighted separately here:
In today’s post, I’ll chart the differences between the three.
Self-Employed Retirement Plan Options
Before I get to which plan I chose to create and why, I compiled a chart that compares the self-employed retirement plans against each other.
|SEP IRA||Solo 401k||SIMPLE IRA|
|Eligibility Requirements||Age 21 or older. Must have worked for the employer (yourself) in at least 3 of the last 5 years. Must have received at least $550 in compensation.||No employees (outside of spouse). No age or service restrictions.||No age restrictions. Must earn a minimum amount specified by the employer during any 2 preceding years, and expect to earn at least $5,000 in the current year.|
|Maximum Contributions as Employee (Self-Employed)||Personal contribution of up to $5,500 ($6,500 for employees age 50 or older) into an individual SEP-, traditional, or Roth IRA. Income restrictions apply.||$18,00 ($24,000 for employees age 50 or older) for 2016. Cannot exceed 100% of compensation.||$12,500 ($15,500 for 50+) in 2016.|
|Maximum Contributions as Employer (Self-Employed)||25% of net earnings up to $53,000 for 2016. Deductible up to 20%. Annual contributions not required.||For self-employed, 25% of net earnings up to $53,000 for 2016. Deductible up to 20%. Annual contributions not required.||Option 1: Match up to 3% of compensation (can be reduced to as low as 1% in any two out of five years) or $12,500 (2016), whichever is less.
Option 2: Contribute 2% up to $5,300 for 2016.
Contributions are required every year.
|Roth Option Possible?||No||Yes (employee contributions). Availability varies by broker.||No|
|Rollover Options||SEP, Roth, & Traditional IRA's, Qualified pre-tax plans (401k), 403b, 457b.||SEP, Roth, & Traditional IRA's, Qualified pre-tax plans (401k), 403b, 457b.||SEP, Roth, & Traditional IRA's, Qualified pre-tax plans (401k), 403b, 457b if after 2 years have passed from employee first participation. No waiting period for rollover to another SIMPLE.|
|Broker Availability||Highest availability of the three plans. Most discount brokers have a SEP IRA account option.||Lowest availability of the three plans. Roth contribution option varies by broker.||Middle availability of the three plans.|
|Administrative Responsibilities||Complete IRS form 5305-SEP (broker handles).|
No IRS reporting required.
|Annual filing of Form 5500 may be required.|
Plan sponsors have various administrative and fiduciary responsibilities.
|Complete IRS form 5304-SIMPLE or 5305-SIMPLE (broker handles).
No IRS reporting required.
SEP IRA vs. Solo 401k vs. SIMPLE IRA
Everyone’s personal situation is different and there is no single definitive superior retirement plan for every individual who earns self-employment income.
So how do you choose?
Your primary considerations should be:
- Do you have a 403b, 401k, or other qualified retirement plan through an employer?
- What level of self-employment income do you earn?
- How much do you want to contribute?
- How much administrative responsibility are you comfortable with?
- What are the associated fees and investment options with each plan?
If the answer to #1 is “no”, then the Solo 401k gives you the highest contribution limits, as it effectively combines the $18,000 employee contribution with the additional ability to contribute 25% of net earnings as employer. However, it does have the drawbacks of more administrative responsibility and limited broker availability (and potentially higher costs). If you are not earning at higher levels, the increased contribution limits might not be worth it, with the drawbacks in mind.
From there, it’s a matter of how much you’d like to contribute, availability, fees, and investment options when choosing between a SIMPLE and SEP.
If the answer to #1 is “yes”, then the SEP IRA is the clear cut winner, in my opinion. Keep in mind that any contributions you make as an employee to a Solo 401k or SIMPLE IRA count against the maximum employee contribution limits and are cumulative between accounts, so the full contribution to a SIMPLE IRA as an employee would have no added benefit. You would be better off simply contributing to your employer’s plan for the employee contribution aspect, especially if a 401k match is involved. And for contributions with the status of “employer” the SEP IRA contribution limits are far higher than the SIMPLE IRA limits. SEP’s also have greater discount broker availability and typically more investment options than SIMPLE’s.
Self-Employed Retirement Plan Calculators
It might also be beneficial to use a calculator to help you figure out which plan might result in the most tax deductible contributions for you. Here are a few retirement plan calculators that can lend a hand:
Self-Employed Retirement Plan Discussion:
Which retirement plan do you use for your self employment income? And why?